Comparison

Qualfacto vs Prolific: MTurk Alternatives for Research in India

For research in India, the strongest MTurk alternatives are recruited participants who are identity-checked before invitation and found by city.

By Jitendra Kumar Nirala, Founder · Updated 12 Nov 2026

Qualfacto

Participant recruitment for paid qualitative research in India

Best for: Paid qualitative studies in Indian cities

vs

Prolific

Self-serve participant pool for online research

Best for: Self-run online surveys

On this page
  1. 01At a glance
  2. 02How each looks
  3. 03Which to choose
  4. 04Detailed comparison
  5. 05Introduction
  6. 06Key takeaways
  7. 07Which MTurk alternatives suit research in India, and where do we fit?
  8. 08Why did MTurk fail research buyers, and does that apply in India?
  9. 09What should you check before you invite anyone?
  10. 10How many people should you recruit to fill your sessions?
  11. 11Why should you choose Qualfacto for research in India?
  12. 12How do you try us on a real brief?
  13. 13How we compared
  14. 14Frequently asked

The short answer

Qualfacto offers this for paid qualitative studies such as interviews: we verify participants before we invite them, recruit by city and run the sessions. Prolific is a self-serve participant pool for online research and lists India among its small participant populations.

At a glance

Countries

Qualfacto
India only
Prolific
40+ countries

Source: Prolific pricing, Nov 2026

Qualitative formats

Qualfacto
Interviews (30 to 120 minutes), focus groups (1 to 3 hours), diary studies, ethnography, shop-alongs, in-home product tests, usability and app tests, online bulletin boards
Prolific
Interviews and focus groups

Source: Prolific interview guide, Nov 2026

Session setting

Qualfacto
Online or in person
Prolific
Video calls on tools such as Zoom, Microsoft Teams or Skype

Source: Prolific interview guide, Nov 2026

How you buy

Qualfacto
Share a brief, we check feasibility and send a tailored proposal; free pilot available
Prolific
Self-serve pay-as-you-go, or managed services with custom pricing

Source: Prolific pricing, Nov 2026

Price to you

Qualfacto
Quoted per project from your brief
Prolific
Platform fee of 42.8% for corporate customers and 33.3% for academic and non-profit

Source: Prolific pricing, Nov 2026

Participant rewards

Qualfacto
Set per study and shared with participants before they take part; processed after participation is completed and validated
Prolific
Recommended £9 or $12 an hour, minimum £6 or $8

Source: Prolific pricing, Nov 2026

How each looks

Qualfacto's website
Qualfacto’s website
Prolific's website
Prolific’s website

Which should you choose?

Choose Qualfacto if

  • Your participants are in India, which is the only country we serve
  • You need identity checked before any invitation goes out
  • You need to recruit by named city, or by household and demographic profile
  • You want moderators supplied and sessions run online or in person
  • You need sessions in languages other than English

Choose Prolific if

  • You run self-serve online surveys yourself
  • You run your own interviews on Zoom, Microsoft Teams or Skype with participants across 40+ countries

Qualfacto vs Prolific, point by point

A check marks the stronger side on that point. Points without a check are even, or depend on what you need.

Recruitment and checks

Participants in India

QualfactoStronger here
People register with a +91 mobile number and a WhatsApp code
Prolific
India listed among countries with small participant populations

Location targeting

QualfactoStronger here
By city, and by household and demographic profile
Prolific
Country of residence and country of birth; US state for US participants

Identity checks

QualfactoStronger here
Before invitation
Prolific
Age and country of residence verified automatically

City check

QualfactoStronger here
Declared city may be compared with the network's approximate city to flag discrepancies for review
Prolific
Country of residence verified automatically

Sessions

Moderation

QualfactoStronger here
We supply moderators
Prolific
You run interviews outside Prolific

Who conducts studies

QualfactoStronger here
Studies may be conducted by us, research partners or other research organisations
Prolific
Interviews and focus groups run outside Prolific

Introduction

Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) permanently closed on 30 September 2026, according to Amazon's own site. This page is for research buyers who used MTurk to hear from people and now need a replacement in India.

On MTurk you posted a task and anyone who qualified on paper could take it. For research, the damage came less from low pay than from people who were not where, or who, they claimed to be. Another crowd, however well run, carries some of that exposure into qualitative work, where one wrong person changes what a whole group says.

Moving to recruited participants in India comes down to five checks: whether identity is verified before an invitation goes out, whether the stated city is checked, whether you can recruit by named city, who moderates and records, and whether sessions run in the participant's own language. Below you get a five-part supplier check, a recruit-over calculation, and a comparison of Qualfacto with Prolific.

Key takeaways

  • For paid qualitative research in India, choose recruited participants who are identity-checked before invitation and found by city. We built Qualfacto for exactly that.
  • In a 2020 analysis of 38 US-targeted MTurk surveys, about 20% of summer 2018 respondents came from a rented server or a non-US address (Kennedy et al., 2020).
  • Location filters at country level are not enough for city-level qualitative work. We recruit by city and supply moderators.
  • To size any recruit, use: people to recruit = sessions needed ÷ (1 − share lost). Twelve interviews with 20% lost means recruiting 15 people.

Which MTurk alternatives suit research in India, and where do we fit?

For research buyers who need people in India for paid qualitative studies, we recommend Qualfacto. We verify participants before we invite them, recruit by city and run the sessions. Recruited participants are people a supplier finds, screens and invites for your specific study, rather than a crowd who choose tasks themselves.

The comparison covers us and Prolific, a self-serve participant pool for online research. Prolific is built for self-run online surveys; for interviews and groups in Indian cities, Qualfacto recruits and runs the sessions.

Why did MTurk fail research buyers, and does that apply in India?

Partly. In the 2018 MTurk data, Venezuela and India were the two largest origins of international respondents, people using rented servers or foreign addresses to appear as US participants. Identity and location are therefore the two questions to settle for any replacement in India.

Kennedy and colleagues analysed 38 studies and 24,930 respondents from 2013 to 2018 (Political Science Research and Methods, 24 April 2020). In summer 2018, about 20% of respondents came from a virtual private server (a rented machine that hides where a user really is) or a non-US internet address. Valid respondents failed quality checks 2.8% of the time. Virtual private server users failed 23.9% and foreign respondents 32.0%, which is about 8.5 and 11 times as often (our arithmetic: 23.9 ÷ 2.8 and 32.0 ÷ 2.8).

These were online surveys aimed at US respondents, and 2018 was a spike, so the figures describe survey fraud in one period. Our inference for qualitative work is that someone who misstates where they live can misstate who they are. In an interview or group, that costs a full session, a moderator's hour and an incentive.

Cost shows the same pattern. A comparison of 2,729 US participants found a cost per high-quality respondent of $4.36 on MTurk, $2.00 on CloudResearch and $1.90 on Prolific (Douglas, Ewell and Brauer, PLOS ONE, 14 March 2023). MTurk cost about 2.3 times Prolific (4.36 ÷ 1.90, our arithmetic).

What should you check before you invite anyone?

Run five checks on any supplier, including us. Each has a pass and a fail you can test in one email.

Is identity verified before an invitation goes out?

Pass: the supplier names what it verifies, such as a mobile number and a person's identity, and confirms the check happens before the invitation. Fail: verification happens only inside the study, or the answer is "we screen carefully".

Ours: participants register with a +91 mobile number and confirm a code sent on WhatsApp, and we run identity checks before any invitation goes out.

Is the stated city checked against anything?

Pass: the supplier can name what it compares the declared city with. Fail: city is a free-text field.

Ours: at registration we may compare the city a person declares with the approximate city of their network connection to flag discrepancies for review. The check does not save the IP address in the profile (our privacy notice).

Can the supplier recruit by named city?

Pass: you can ask for eight people in Pune and eight in Lucknow and get a feasibility answer for each city. Fail: only country-level filters. Prolific's location filters are country of residence and country of birth, plus US state for US participants (Prolific filters guide).

Ours: we recruit by city, and by household and demographic profile.

Who moderates, records and delivers?

Pass: the quote says who moderates, whether sessions are recorded and transcribed, and who writes the report, before fieldwork starts. Fail: responsibility is left unstated until the day.

Ours: we can supply moderators. Recordings, transcripts, structured data exports and research reports are included depending on the scope we agree with you before the study begins. Market research fieldwork explains who does what.

Can sessions run in the participant's own language?

Pass: the screener, moderator and guide are in the language the participant speaks at home, confirmed in writing. Fail: English-only sessions for a mixed-language audience.

Ours: we run sessions in languages other than English. Multilingual research explains what to specify.

In our judgement, failing the first or second check matters most. A wrong person or wrong city cannot be fixed by a better moderator.

How many people should you recruit to fill your sessions?

Divide the sessions you need by the share of recruited people who will remain after identity checks, screening and no-shows. This is our model, not a published rate.

Formula: people to recruit = sessions needed ÷ (1 − share lost).

  • 12 interviews, 20% lost: 12 ÷ 0.80 = 15 people.
  • 12 interviews, 30% lost: 12 ÷ 0.70 = 17.1, so recruit 18.

Use 20% and 30% as example loss rates, not published rates. Replace them with the loss rate from your last project. Over-recruitment and incidence rate screening maths show how to size the screener.

Why should you choose Qualfacto for research in India?

Choose us when your participants are in India and the session matters more than the click. We serve India only, run identity checks before invitation, recruit by city and by household and demographic profile, and run paid qualitative formats with moderators we supply, including online bulletin boards. We price each project from your brief, and you can ask for a free pilot.

How do you try us on a real brief?

Email your brief to support@qualfacto.io with the objective, method, audience, city, sample size, languages and timeline. We review it for feasibility and send a tailored proposal. Ask about a free pilot. We reply during business hours, Monday to Friday, 10:00 to 18:00 Indian Standard Time (IST), and aim to answer within one business day. Longer enquiries may take more time.

Our verdict

For research in India, choose Qualfacto: it verifies identity before invitation, recruits by city and supplies the moderators.

How we compared

Qualfacto publishes this page and is one of the two services compared. Prolific's details are as on its own pages in November 2026.

This page is published by qualfacto. If anything here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.

Sources

  1. 1.Amazon Mechanical Turk: closure notice, Amazon, November 2026
  2. 2.Kennedy et al., "The shape of and solutions to the MTurk quality crisis", Political Science Research and Methods, 24 April 2020
  3. 3.Douglas, Ewell and Brauer, "Data quality in online human-subjects research", PLOS ONE, 14 March 2023
  4. 4.Prolific pricing, Prolific, November 2026
  5. 5.Prolific help: Who are the participants on Prolific?, Prolific, 18 June 2026
  6. 6.Prolific help: How do I use Prolific's filters?, Prolific, November 2026
  7. 7.Prolific help: How do I run video interviews and focus groups?, Prolific, November 2026
  8. 8.Qualfacto privacy notice, Qualfacto, November 2026

Frequently asked

No. Amazon Mechanical Turk permanently closed on 30 September 2026, as the notice on mturk.com states. If you used it to reach people for research, replace it with a source that verifies identity and location before invitation. For paid qualitative studies in India, that is what we recruit.
For research in India, we recommend Qualfacto: we verify identity before invitation, recruit by city and supply moderators, and we run the sessions online or in person. Prolific's own guide lists India among its small participant populations, so city-level qualitative recruitment is not its strength.
Yes. We recruit by city and can target by household and demographic profile, then run the session online or in person. Eligibility and invitations depend on each project's requirements and the participant's profile, so we confirm feasibility for your city before fieldwork is agreed.
Qualfacto is not a task marketplace. It is a participant panel for paid qualitative research such as interviews, group discussions, diary studies and product tests. Joining is free, and you can register to be considered for suitable studies. Registration does not guarantee selection or invitations, and rewards, eligibility and timelines depend on each study's terms.
Yes, we offer research buyers a free pilot. We review your brief for feasibility, then send a tailored proposal, so you can see how we recruit and run sessions before you scale up. Pricing for the full study is set project by project from your methodology, audience, sample and geography.

Try Qualfacto on a real research brief in India

Email your brief with the objective, method, audience, city, sample size, languages and timeline, and ask about a free pilot.
Send your brief